1. LaDainian Tomlinson 2. Priest Holmes 3. Edgerrin James 4. Shaun Alexander 5. Jamal Lewis 6. Corey Dillon 7. Domanick Davis 8. Clinton Portis 9. Julius Jones 10. Rudi Johnson
They didn't post their scoring guidelines online, but let's assume that it is standard 1 point per 10 yards rushing, 1 point per 10 yards receiving, 6 points per rushing/receiving TD, -2 per fumble.
I like The_Dogs list alot better than than NFL.coms. He has Holmes lower, as should be expected given his age, questionable durability and the presence of Larry Johnson. Also, substituting McGahee in for Julius Jones makes sense, as McGahee really shined when he took over for good in Buffalo (not that Julius Jones didn't, but he has to prove he is durable).
It could also be argued that Domanick Davis and Ahman Green should be excluded from both lists and replaced by Kevin Jones at around the 6 or 7 spot.
Logged
"A child of five could understand this (someone fetch me a child of five)" - Groucho Marx
1. LT2 2. Edge 3. Deuce McAllister 4. Jamal Lewis 5. Shaun Alexander 6. McGahee 7. Julius Jones 8. Kevin Jones 9. Clinton Portis 10. Corey Dillon
Just my opinion
Logged
All Hail Emperor Landry I...The Original DUKE Of DOOM!!!!!!! 2003 Insane League CHAMPION! 2004 Insane League Championship Game Runner-up!! 2005 Score Wars III: Revenge of The DUKE!!!...aaah, NUTS!!
1. Ladanian Tomlimson 2. Priest Holmes 3. Shaun Alexander 4. Corey Dillon 5. Edgerrin James 6. Willis Mcgahee 7. Tiki Barber 8. Jamal Lewis 9. Rudi Johnson 10.Clinton Portis
I still have holmes high cause he hasnt shown he is gonna slow down...when he is healthy he is still a beast.....the only guy im Iffy about is clinton portis im not sure if he is top 10 anymore...he is borderline to me....Mcgahee will have a very nice year as will the rest....i wouldnt be surprised if domanick davis took the 10 spot from portis....
All Hail Emperor Landry I...The Original DUKE Of DOOM!!!!!!! 2003 Insane League CHAMPION! 2004 Insane League Championship Game Runner-up!! 2005 Score Wars III: Revenge of The DUKE!!!...aaah, NUTS!!
packers lost BOTH of their pro bowl guards this offseason...one to dallas and one to carolina....so the running game is a big IF at this point not to mention the defense stinks which means farve will probably have to throw more.....
1. LaDainian Tomlinson 2. Jamal Lewis 3. Shaun Alexander 4. Priest Holmes 5. Deuce McAllister 6. Willis MaGahee 7. Kevin Jones 8. Edgerrin James 9. Tiki Barber 10. Rudi Johnson
1. LaDainian Thomlinson 2. Shaun Alexander 3. Willis McGahee 4. Jamal Lewis 5. Deuce McAllister 6. Edgerrin James 7. Clinton Portis 8. Kevin Jones 9. Julius Jones 10. Priest Holmes
Someone save this thread. We'll look at it in January.
Logged
“If life gives you lemons make orange juice. Let the rest of the world figure out how you did it.”