Fantasyfootballer.com's Gridiron


    
      
        Fantasyfootballer.com's Gridiron
        (https://www.fantasyfootballer.com/cgi-bin/theGridiron/YaBB.cgi)
      

        the Gridiron >> the Red Zone >>  1 BIG TRADE QUESTION PLEASE HELP
        
(Message started by: jabenus on Oct 6^th, 2005, 6:48pm)

Title: 1 BIG TRADE QUESTION PLEASE HELP
Post by jabenus on Oct 6^th, 2005, 6:48pm

I HAVE BEEN OFFERED
CARSON PALMER AND DOMANICK DAVIS
FOR
DONOVAN MCNABB AND REGGIE WAYNE.

SHOULD I DO THIS TRADE?

MY TEAM IS
================
QB D. McNabb
QB M. Brunell
WR T. Owens
WR R. Wayne
WR A. Boldin
WR L. Coles
WR L. Evans
RB M. Pittman
RB R. Johnson
RB R. Williams
RB F. Taylor
TE A. Gates
K J. Kasay
DEF Jacksonville Defense

Title: Re: 1 BIG TRADE QUESTION PLEASE HELP
Post by MordecaiCourage on Oct 6^th, 2005, 7:00pm

Damn Jabenus...that's a tough one!!!
I love McNabb...he puts up giant numbers even though he is hurt....throws to the best WR in the game.....throws to a pretty good RB and TE too!!!
Wayne has the greatest QB in the game throwing to him.

Hold the phone

Palmer puts up pretty good numbers too...throws to a pretty great WR as well....

Dom Davis is the biggest ? for you here! He is the central part of the offense in Houston.......heck.... he IS the offense in Houston!! You could use the help at RB too.

Seems pretty fair...I really don't know what to tell you bro!! This trade frightens me for some reason!!!! [smiley=scared.gif] Could it be tweeked any at all?

Title: Re: 1 BIG TRADE QUESTION PLEASE HELP
Post by rickgpin on Oct 6^th, 2005, 9:32pm

i like the trade depending on how may rbs and wrs you start. if you start 3 wrs, your third is a big weak. otherwise, i say go for it. [smiley=yes.gif]

i like mourdecai's idea of a possible tweak. coles or evans instead of wayne is probably too much to ask but....

good luck.

Title: Re: 1 BIG TRADE QUESTION PLEASE HELP
Post by StegRock on Oct 6^th, 2005, 10:02pm

I would NOT do this deal. I would not do this kind of deal until you see how Ricky comes back. You've got Rudi and Taylor, and Pittman for at least this week and probably a little more. Adding Davis would only add to the confusion as to who to start week in and week out at RB,... and considering Murphy's Law you'll always choose the wrong 2 (or 3). On the other hand, given your receiving corps, you kind of NEED to keep Wayne. I would hold off, for now at least.

Title: Re: 1 BIG TRADE QUESTION PLEASE HELP
Post by Referee on Oct 6^th, 2005, 10:35pm

on 10/06/05 at 22:23:35, jabenus wrote:

DO YOU GUYS THINK I SHOULD TRADE REGGIE WAYNE FOR DOMANICK DAVIS

MY TEAM IS
================
QB D. McNabb
QB M. Brunell
WR T. Owens
WR R. Wayne
WR A. Boldin
WR L. Coles
WR L. Evans
RB M. Pittman
RB R. Johnson
RB R. Williams
RB F. Taylor
TE A. Gates
K J. Kasay
DEF Jacksonville Defense

Title: Re: 1 BIG TRADE QUESTION PLEASE HELP
Post by StegRock on Oct 8^th, 2005, 3:14pm

Dude, this "new" trade is so similar to the trade that you originally posed that my response above still applies word-for-word...

on 10/06/05 at 22:02:17, StegRock wrote:

Sit tight... [smiley=getoff.gif] and good luck! [smiley=shamrock.gif]