Fantasyfootballer.com's Gridiron


    
      
        Fantasyfootballer.com's Gridiron
        (https://www.fantasyfootballer.com/cgi-bin/theGridiron/YaBB.cgi)
      

        the Gridiron >> the Red Zone >>  Would you do this trade??
        
(Message started by: The Juror on Sep 19^th, 2007, 9:52am)

Title: Would you do this trade??
Post by The Juror on Sep 19^th, 2007, 9:52am

A guy who has LT has made me an offer

LT

Braylon Edwards or Vincent Jackson

Donovan McNabb or Philip Rivers

For

Westbrook or Willie Parker

Randy Moss

Jon Kitna

I am 2-0 and my other WR’s are Reggie Wayne and Steve Smith. He is 0-2

My other QB is Eli.

Title: Re: Would you do this trade??
Post by MordecaiCourage on Sep 19^th, 2007, 11:26am

I would do it Keith. You have Wayne and Smith already..that's a pretty solid WR corp. I think I'd send him Parker over Westy if you get RB receiving points, if it's straight rushing yards I'd keep Parker. Take Edwards over Jackson. In my mind, it's a toss up between McNabb and Rivers. I can't help but think McNabb is gonna get hurt again. Nothing but my gut on that call though. Good luck. If this is a keeper league..definately take the deal and make it Rivers as QB as it would make you younger.

Title: Re: Would you do this trade??
Post by steelkings on Sep 19^th, 2007, 12:26pm

Lets look at this for what it is. This guy is Offering LT for (Parker Or westbrook) and Moss.

Of the others:
1. McNabb right now is in a bad place. Playing poorly and playing the race card on HBO is added pressure that could cause him trouble in the focus department. He in MHO is a risky aquisition at best. Not to mention he's not much better than Kitna fantasy wise to begin with.

2. Edwards and the Browns were almost non existant against the Steelers two weeks ago. The Bungles "D" is horrible. Dont count on the Browns hanging 51 on anyone else. They should get back to their normal selves shortly.

3. Rivers is ok, but he's being dangled like a carrot. You could find yourself hoping both rivers and LT have monster days at the same time. Not likely.

4. Your opponent has too many Chargers and he's trying to make that someone elses problem by including V. Jackson.

5. Parker and Moss are two of the reasons why you are 2 and 0. I would not want to part with two guys who are on a serious roll.

Like MC said, if this is a keeper league then that changes alot. It could draw a counter from you. However if not , there is no way I do this deal. NO WAY!

Title: Re: Would you do this trade??
Post by StegRock on Sep 23^rd, 2007, 5:34am

I'm ultimately with sk on this one. Even if it's a keeper (though), I'd stay put. The ultimate turn-off for me is the fact that Edwards and Jackson are still, a couple decent performances early in the season aside, dime-a-dozeners. I do think Moss is back. You'd be giving up two blue-chippers and another good statistical guy for one, granted the biggest of all, blue-chipper, one of two guys you'd be crossing your fingers on to turn it around and one of two guys who's basically a dime-a-dozener or only a step above being so. That don't work for me.

Title: Re: Would you do this trade??
Post by The Juror on Sep 23^rd, 2007, 8:03am

Thanks for all you input gents....always appreciated!! [smiley=wave.gif]